Daily Health Headlines

Exercise Has Its Limits for Losing Weight, Study Finds

👤by Amy Norton 0 comments 🕔Friday, January 29th, 2016

THURSDAY, Jan. 28, 2016 (HealthDay News) -- That daily 5-mile run may not be burning as many calories as you think, a new study suggests.

In fact, the researchers found, moderate exercise -- the equivalent of walking a couple miles per day -- may be the best way to burn extra calories. Beyond that, the body seems to adapt its metabolism so that calorie-burning plateaus, no matter how hard you work out.

The findings, published online Jan. 28 in the journal Current Biology, may sound counterintuitive -- or at least disappointing.

"The predominant view is that the more active you are, the more calories you burn every day," said lead researcher Herman Pontzer, an associate professor of anthropology at City University of New York's Hunter College.

This study, according to Pontzer, supports a different view: "It's really not a simple dose-response relationship," he said. "The body adapts to exercise, and it begins adapting at a moderate level of activity."

His team arrived at that conclusion after studying 332 adults, aged 25 to 45, from the United States, Ghana, Jamaica, Seychelles and South Africa.

All of the participants wore a device that recorded their activity levels for a week, and the researchers used standard tests to measure each person's total calorie-burning for the week.

Predictably, people with moderate activity levels burned somewhat more daily calories than sedentary people did -- an extra 200 per day, on average.

But more intense activity brought no additional benefit -- at least as far as calories.

Pontzer stressed that exercise has many benefits for a person's health in general. "There's nothing in this study that suggests exercise is anything but good for you," he said.

But if your goal is weight loss, exercise alone is unlikely to cut it. And that message, Pontzer noted, is not new.

"We know that diet changes are the most effective way to lose weight," he said. "This study adds another piece of evidence to support that."

Two researchers who were not involved in the study agreed that exercise alone isn't enough.

"The reality is, exercise by itself is not great for weight loss," said Dr. Timothy Church, a professor of preventative medicine at Pennington Biomedical Research Center, in Baton Rouge, La.

But, he added, exercise does boost weight loss from diet changes -- and it helps people keep the pounds off.

Dr. Chip Lavie, director of exercise laboratories at the Ochsner Heart and Vascular Institute in New Orleans, made the same point.

"Also," he said, "there are numerous benefits of exercise besides just weight loss."

According to Lavie, those benefits include improved fitness (with high-intensity exercise generally getting better results), a lower risk of heart disease, stress relief -- and fun.

But why wouldn't greater amounts of exercise help the body burn more calories every day? Behavior could partly explain it, according to Pontzer: When people exert themselves at the gym or on a run, they might compensate by sitting or lying down more throughout the rest of the day.

But Pontzer thinks there is also a physiological adaptation. In an earlier study, he and his colleagues focused on the Hadza, a traditional hunter-gatherer population in Tanzania. The Hadza are highly active every day, Pontzer said -- walking long distances and performing hard physical labor.

And yet, his team found, the average Hadza adult burns a similar number of calories each day as the typical American.

In the new study, there was a point at which the daily calorie burn from exercise leveled off. Pontzer described it as the equivalent of walking a couple miles per day.

But, Church pointed out, there appeared to be relatively few study participants who got much more exercise than that. And that makes it harder to draw firm conclusions.

Plus, he said, the typical American falls far short of the "line" where calorie-burning plateaued in this study.

"I question how much this would mean to the average American trying to lose weight," Church said. "Physical activity is going to add to calorie expenditure for the vast majority of them."

Article Credits / Source

Amy Norton / HealthDay

Amy Norton wrote this story for HealthDay. HealthDay provides up to the minute breaking health news. Click here to view this full article from HealthDay.

SOURCES: Herman Pontzer, Ph.D., associate professor, anthropology, City University of New York-Hunter College, New York City; Timothy Church, M.D., Ph.D., M.P.H., professor, preventative medicine, Pennington Biomedical Research Center, Louisiana State University, Baton Rouge; Carl "Chip" Lavie, M.D., director, exercise laboratories, Ochsner Heart and Vascular Institute, Ochsner Medical Center, New Orleans; Jan. 28, 2016, Current Biology, online

View More Articles From Amy Norton 🌎View Article Website

Sponsored Product

Lunar Sleep for $1.95

Lunar Sleep for $1.95

People who have trouble sleeping typically have low levels of melatonin, so melatonin supplements seem like a logical fix for insomnia. There is a high demand for sleep aids, especially in the U.S. The National Health Interview Survey done in 2002, and again in 2007, found 1.6 million US adults were using complementary and alternative sleep aids for insomnia. Lunar Sleep was a top choice. Use Promo Code: Sleep2014 and only pay $1.95 S&H.

Get Lunar Sleep for $1.95

More Exercise & Fitness Articles

Health Tip: Don't Nullify Your Workout

Health Tip: Don't Nullify Your Workout0

(HealthDay News) -- The wrong meals and snacks can thwart your attempts to exercise, burn calories and tone up. The Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics suggests: Don't overestimate how many calories you are using through exercise. Remember ...

Health Tip: Don't Fall for Exercise Myths

Health Tip: Don't Fall for Exercise Myths0

(HealthDay News) -- Exercise is a great way to stay healthy and shed pounds. But don't believe everything you hear. Here's the truth about working out, courtesy of the National Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney ...

Health Tip: Vary Your Workout Routine

Health Tip: Vary Your Workout Routine0

(HealthDay News) -- You can get into a rut when it comes to your exercise routine, so it's wise to add variety to your regimen. The American Council on Exercise suggests these possibilities: Adjust the number of repetitions in a set or the ...

How to Exercise Safely in Smog

How to Exercise Safely in Smog0

FRIDAY, Nov. 11, 2016 (HealthDay News) -- Scientists say they have figured out the ideal speeds for cyclists and pedestrians to move in order to limit their inhalation of air pollution and still get the full benefits of exercise. "The faster ...

Friendly Competition on Social Media May Get You to the Gym

Friendly Competition on Social Media May Get You to the Gym0

TUESDAY, Nov. 8, 2016 (HealthDay News) -- Social media can be a powerful motivating tool. But if your goal is to get to the gym more often, competition beats friendly support on social networking sites, a new study contends. "Supportive groups ...

View More Exercise & Fitness Articles


Write a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Our Mailing List

Subscribe to our mailing list to get the latest health news as it breaks!

Your information will not be shared with anyone!